Victoria S. Pelak, MD
There is not a “one-size-fits all” approach to helping compensate for visual brain dysfunction. We often hear from our patients and their care what helped and what did not and with that information, we put together this document. We also relied upon tips put together by a team at the Multidisciplinary Memory Clinic at the University of Toronto that included Alison Lake OT, Maria Martinez MSW and David F. Tang-Wai MDCM FRCPC. The complete list of those tips are freely available here -
PCA Tip Sheet for Patients
From the Eyes to the Brain: Vision is a complex process that begins in the
eyes. In order to see what our eyes detect, visual signals from the eye must be sent to the brain. One of the most important regions of the brain that receive information directly from the eyes is a region called the thalamus, which is a structure
in the deep center of the brain. From there, information travels to the posterior lobe of the brain called the occipital cortex. The cortex is a special type of brain tissue and regions of the cortex are dedicated to a variety of different functions.
For instance, the cortex helps create our memories, interpret and produce language and speech, processes information from the five senses, and helps control voluntary movements. The occipital cortex is an area that is solely dedicated to vision. After
it receives visual information from the thalamus, the occipital cortex works to provide feedback to the thalamus to control what visual information we pay attention to and it also sends information out to other regions of the brain so we can act upon
what we are seeing or recognize what we are seeing and compare it to our stored memories. Beyond the cortex, the eyes also send information to our brain stem and an area called the hypothalamus; the vital visual information sent to these regions helps
our brain control eye movements, the focusing power of the eye, and the sleep-wake cycle.
Detecting Visual Brain Dysfunction:
Testing the basic visual function of the eye and the eye examination do not readily lead to the detection of visual brain dysfunction. Instead, the examiner must be looking specifically for visual brain dysfunction and those types of tests
are not part of the routine eye visit. For example, a common test to evaluate cognitive brain processes that rely on vision includes copying a geometric figure or a clock drawing test. When either is abnormal, it is a clue that visual brain
dysfunction is likely present. Interpretation of a complex visual image or scene can also be part of the assessment for visual brain dysfunction. This type of testing can reveal decreased visual attention, particularly
for objects in the left half of a person’s vision, or abnormal visual detection of the overall scene. In summary, measuring visual brain dysfunction requires specialized tests and assessments
usually administered by a neurologist or a neuropsychologist during cognitive testing.
Impact on Everyday Activity:When visual brain dysfunction is present, there are many everyday activities that become difficult or impossible to perform, particularly when the dysfunction is combined with apraxia, which is the inability to properly perform a task that requires purposeful movements (i.e. dressing or using a smart phone). Although many brain processes are important for driving a vehicle, when visual brain activities are disrupted, driving can be impacted early in the course of disease. A person might have difficulty with parallel parking or hug the line on the road too closely; they might misjudge the speed of oncoming vehicles when turning left at stoplights through oncoming traffic. These are distinctive signs of visual brain dysfunction and are important to recognize for safety reasons.
Supportive Approaches: There are ways that might help compensate for these problems and what works best is unique to each person. Thus, suggestions could work for some but not others or you might find some of your own alternative approaches to help you manage everyday activities. Below we review suggestions to help you get started to offset the impact of visual brain dysfunction.
Suggestions to Help
First steps: Eye Care and Prescription Lenses
One of the first steps to improve visual function in the setting of any type of dementia is to make sure your eyes are as healthy as possible and your prescription lenses are up-to-date and appropriate for the various points of focus you use every day (i.e. distance, mid-range, and near). Some eye doctors might not be aware of how the brain impacts vision, but they can provide the type of important eye care health that you need as you age.
General eye care:There are many eye changes that occur as we age. Not only is it difficult to focus up close as we age, otherwise known as presbyopia, but our eyes can become dryer and we can develop age-related eye disorders such as cataracts, macular degeneration, and glaucoma. Schedule annual visits to your ophthalmologist even if you think your glasses are the proper prescription because changes can occur inside the eye before you notice the consequence and early treatment can prevent vision loss. For those with diabetes, routine eye care is critical to preventing blindness.
While seeing your eye care provider for prescription lenses, let them know of your diagnosis of visual brain dysfunction and that it might impact your ability to use the lenses they prescribe, particularly those lenses that have
corrections for different distances within the lens and these include progressive lenses, trifocals, and bifocals. These types of lenses require small eye movements, sometimes combined with slight adjustments in neck position, to get
the eyes to be looking through the proper portion of the lens in order to see things in focus. For those with ocular motor slowing or inaccurate adjustment of the eyes to focus at different distances, these types of multifocal point
lenses can be difficult to use. The eyes can also have a hard time moving toward each other and when this happens, which is called convergence insufficiency, it can be difficult to read without blur or seeing double. If convergence
insufficiency is causing problems with near reading or other near work, the eye care provider might be able to add prisms to your reading lenses to help improve your near vision. Thus, seeking out proper lenses as soon as visual symptoms
become evident when reading or attempting to change focus at different distances is worthwhile.
Visual Hallucinations can occur and be a challenging problem to cope with throughout the course. If the visual hallucinations are frightening or if a person is having difficulty recognizing the unreal nature of the hallucinations, the use of medication is an important method of treatment to prevent behavioral changes that lead to disruption or safety issues. Non-medication approaches can be tried even in conjunction with medications and these approaches include the following:
- when hallucinations are frightening, reassure the person they are safe and consider moving to another room
- increase the lighting and visual and auditory stimulation with activities such as watching a movie or listening to music or books on tape
- prevent spending long periods of time in dim lighting or dark rooms other than when asleep
- with the help of the prescribing doctor, eliminate medications that cloud the mind if and whenever possible
- prevent sleep deprivation with good sleep practices and maintaining the proper day-night schedule
- as noted in the Eye Care and Prescription Lenses section, treat eye conditions and keep up to date on prescription lenses since poor vision can also lead to visual hallucinations
Many family members and care partners ask whether gently trying to persuade a person that a visual hallucination is not real is the right thing to do when a person believes the hallucination is real. The answer to this is dependent
upon the circumstance. If a person is asking for reassurance that what they are seeing is not real, then it is appropriate to comfort the person and help them gain insight that the hallucination is not real. In other circumstances,
a person might be more upset by being told or trying to be convinced that what they see is not real than how they feel about the hallucination itself. As an example, a person might create a story regarding a non-frightening visual
hallucination and if they are convinced of the real nature of the hallucination, it might be best to acknowledge the story and simply move on. In another circumstance, a visual hallucination might be frightening, and it then becomes
necessary to make the person feel safe and comfortable and move out of the room or space where the hallucination is being experienced and reassure the person that they are safe and protected. In situations where a person does not
feel safe due to recurrent visual hallucinations, medication treatment is the best approach. In summary, if the act of trying to convince a person with a visual hallucination that it is not real becomes upsetting for the person
to hear or does not provide reassurance or comfort, then it is best to make the person feel safe and consider increasing the lighting, moving to another room, and trying to engage the person in another activity if at all possible.
Visual brain function can be very dependent on the level of light and the source of lighting. If the room is too bright, it can be difficult to distinguish words on a page or objects from the background. If the room is too dark, the
same problem can occur. Find the best light for the task at hand, whether that is eating, watching TV, looking at photos on a phone or other device, looking at a computer monitor, etc. It is usually somewhere between dim and bright
for most people with visual brain dysfunction. The light source is also important. Overhead lighting from can lights in particular can create a glare that makes it difficult to see, although use of a dimmer on can lighting can
help keep the room well-lit without the brightness that can wash out what is being viewed. Experiment with different lighting environments during the day and evening by bringing different lamps into a room, opening or closing curtains
depending on the time of the day, and changing the brightness of overhead lighting. By increasing the contrast between the background and what you are looking at will be easier to see. See the section on
Contrast and Electronic Devices
On nearly all electronic devices, the level of contrast for text and images can be adjusted. To determine how to do so, you can search the internet for your device and type “how to change contrast”. Once you are able to
adjust the contrast, you can try different levels, but the best for most with visual brain dysfunction is to have the contrast at the greatest level possible, often listed as 100% on devices. The brightness of text can also be
adjusted and the brightness that you want will depend on the background. If the background is white, the brighter the text or image, the harder it is to see because it will blend in with the background. If the background is black,
the brighter image will be easier to see. The best way to determine what is right for the person with visual brain dysfunction is to experiment. In general, increasing the contrast from what is being viewed and the background will
be one way to improve visual function.
Avoid flooring that has grey upon grey or white upon white when adding an area rug to a carpet or flooring. These items can become hazards as they will blend into the background and not be able to be seen.
Finding and Seeing Items
Many people with visual brain dysfunction are not able to find items that are directly in sight or in plain view. At other times, the smallest piece of paper or a very small item can easily be seen. We now understand that the visual brain can miss seeing an item when it is within a cluttered environment or when it is mixed in with a lot of other items such as trying to find a hairbrush on a dresser or bathroom counter that is filled with other items or even a fork on a dining room table. A key to helping to compensate for this problem is to simplify and declutter the environment.
Ideas to help see and find items you need
- Everyday items: Place only the essential items for everyday use in view on counters, on dressers, and in bathrooms and separate items in an organized way.
- Everyday items: Add brightly colored tape to items used every day if they become difficult to find even when they are in a decluttered and organized environment. For example, hot and cold water faucet labels
- Telling time: Even in the early stages, the use of an analog or digital watch can be difficult to use. Some find that the use of a low vision talking watch can be quite helpful; there are many brands and styles to choose from and some are inexpensive and simply give the time when a button is pushed. Others can add recorded reminders or give the time at specified intervals. In fact, exploring the world of items for the low-sighted might lead to useful devices to help in everyday activities. Since most of the items were designed for vision loss related to eye disease and not for people with dementia or cognitive impairment, they don’t always provide the type of support that is necessary, but they are worth exploring. At the end of this document is a list of smart phone or tablet applications for electronic devices for the blind or low-sighted that are worth exploring.
- Dimensional Fabric Paint: Paint that dries to a 3-dimensional configuration (i.e. a large, thick dot) is available in many colors and comes in easy-squeeze bottles so they’re user friendly. This can be used by placing a DOT on anything from the 30 second setting on a microwave to anything that you commonly use around the house so that it makes it easier to identify. This type of paint can be purchased at any craft store and even hardware stores and online stores.
- Clothing: Organize closets into sections. For instance, separate shirts from tops and from pants and accessories. Alternatively, some people have learned that creating outfits and placing each outfit on one hanger (i.e. an entire outfit on a hanger including the accessories) in the closet so that you can pull out one hanger and not have to search for items can be very helpful.
- Clothing: Organize clothing drawers in a similar manner to closets and some people have found that having a photograph or other label placed on the drawer is useful. Similar labeling can be used in any room where it helps limit frustration when looking for an item.
- Clothing: Eliminate clothes not worn frequently so that closets and drawers have fewer pieces of clothing. Put into storage any items that are out of season.
- All items: Keep items in the same place and when you find them out-of-place be sure to let everyone know you are putting it “back” in its proper place. Many people with visual brain dysfunction find it frustrating when other people move items, even if it is moved to keep things organized. So, always communicate about organizing and when moving an item. Find convenient locations to keep items where you use them. For instance, always keep glasses in one location or in a special, easy-to-see container (e.g. place glasses in a bright blue box on the table near where you read) and try to always put them back in that location.
- Areas and rooms: Set aside areas of a room or areas within the house where certain items will always be and/or activities will take place. So, depending on a person’s hobby or interest, create a reading area or an area to view photo albums, an area to craft, an area to tinker or fix items, a TV watching area, a music listening area, etc. Create the area so that it has all the items you need to do the activity.
- Medication Supervision: Medication supervision is something that should be established early since pills can look the same and be difficult to take on schedule even when pills are in a pill container labeled by the day. Options to consider is the use of one container for each day instead of a container that has one week or more supplied in separate sections. Work with your prescribing doctor to try to simplify medication routines (use of long-acting medications that can be taken daily or eliminating medications started years ago but might not be needed as frequently or at all).
- Reading material: More often than not, even in the early stages, reading can be very difficult. For those who can still read by struggle, a few ideas to prolong the skill of reading include the following: large print with strong contrast (described in Contrast section) might be helpful; clear away any other items from the surface you are reading; avoid printed material on glossy pages, which can be very difficult to read for people with visual brain dysfunction; use a ruler or other similar item to help move from line to line (it might take some practice); avoid trying to read a page with a lot of different sections and paragraphs and photos (e.g. front page of a newspaper) because this can be confusing to the visual brain that is not fully functional – and to eliminate this problem, consider downloading one article at a time to print off or cut the article out of the newspaper.
- Audio instead of reading: Of course, there will come a time when audiobooks will be the best alternative. The National Federation of the Blind
offers access to national newspapers, including the Wall Street Journal and USA Today and other deliverables. They state on their webpages that “Anyone who cannot read
printed publications due to vision loss, dyslexia, or a physical disability is eligible to receive NFB-NEWSLINE.” You can register by “calling your state's Library
for the Blind and Physically Handicapped or the National Federation of the Blind at 866-504-7300 to request an application.” You may also download and mail an application
or complete their online application. After your registration is processed, you will receive a message containing your activation codes and instructions. The benefits include
access to news sources, including CNN, BBC, and ESPN Online and international newspapers, including Financial Times and Vancouver Sun and magazines, including Time, Consumer Reports,
Guideposts, and Smithsonian, state newspapers, emergency weather alerts and seven-day forecasts localized to your zip code or GPS location as well as access to the National Federation
for the Blind’s national channel.
- Overall, observe what is the most frustrating or the most difficult to do and try to find ways to increase contrast and increase ease of performing a task from the perspective of asking… “Could the problem be with visual perception”.
Focus on the ideas that you believe will make the biggest impact and then give it a try. Invite a family member or friend or grandchild to help you implement them. Others often have ideas that are creative and uniquely suited to
the individual with visual brain dysfunction.
Finding Your Way, Not Getting Lost, and Staying Safe
Wandering and getting lost are common for people with brain dysfunction affecting the visual areas of the brain; these visual areas help create the maps that are stored in your memory and if there is difficulty using vision to
gain access to these memories, wandering and getting lost can be a concern for safety. Some people report that their loved one with visual brain dysfunction was at one moment at their side and then gone the next, especially
in a new location (e.g. at a store with which they are not familiar). Even getting from one location to another in the house can become difficult. Some ways that have helped others are listed below.
When outside the home:
- Walking through a grocery store or going for a walk outside can be difficult with visual brain dysfunction. The family member or care partner who accompanies the person with visual brain dysfunction can choose to wear a distinctive hat or shirt to help a person follow them or keep them in sight. For instance, a bright color or always choose the same color when outside. Discuss the distinctive piece of clothing before leaving the house and then again when outside as a reminder.
- People with severe visual brain dysfunction can choose to use a cane for the blind and low sighted (i.e. white cane with red tip) to help detect changing slopes of the ground or other objects in the way. Even if the cane is not needed to avoid objects, the use of the cane can alert people to move out of the way and allow one to be recognized as visually challenged. This is strongly recommended for a person who prefers to be more independent but can’t always negotiate new spaces when outside the home. Most canes use a telescoping mechanism that allow them to elongate and shortens easily to be put into use and put away quickly. These canes are offered for free from a variety of different local and national associations. One option is the National Federation of the Blind and the link is here for the application:
- For walking independently outside the home when that is still possible, routes should be created ahead of time with major markers of the route identified before the walk and reviewed carefully before the walk. For instance, many people want to enjoy a walk around the neighborhood for exercise and do so alone. When this is still possible and safe to do without getting lost, exploring a route with the person with visual brain dysfunction so that the route identifiers (e.g. large blue house is where you turn to go around the block) are identified and practiced in advance of attempting to do this independently to ensure safety is important.
- Dogs and service animals: Obtaining and training a service animal can be a long process and most programs require a person to be confident in orientation and mobility skills and be able to navigate a minimum number of routes independently. Furthermore, one safety concern is getting tangled up with leashes and other devices used to harness the animal can lead to falls. We have experienced this with several patients who report a fall when walking their own dog. In summary, guide animals are not usually trained to be helpful for a person with dementia and visual brain dysfunction who wishes to walk more independently outside the home. This does not preclude having a service animal within the home, which can be trained by a family member.
Inside the home:
- Place a sign with an arrow pointing the direction to important rooms (e.g. the bathroom) on a path that seems to create confusion for the person with visual brain dysfunction. Others have found that a sign on the door of the bathroom can be just as useful.
- Consider creative ways to highlight certain rooms (doorframe painted a different color or signs on doors).
- Create unique pathways so that every hallway or path does not look the same. You can do so with adhesive tape on floor/or carpet tape – but be careful to not create tripping hazards.
- Kitchen can be labeled using a variety of different methods that suit your needs. See the document here - PCA Tip Sheet for Patients
- Stairways can be hazardous for people who have difficulty judging depth and contrast. There are many safety adjustments that can be made such as railings that extend past the top and bottom of the first step and brighten the path to the stairway and on the stairway. Create safety barriers in front of stairs to prevent injury. For those with severe brain dysfunction a stairway might not reveal the same depth that it once had or even look like a stairway. To prevent falls down steps or stairs, install a gait or other safety barrier that alerts a person to the step or stairs.
Getting Dressed with less Frustration
As noted in the Finding and Seeing Items section, keeping closets organized and minimizing the number of clothing items in closets and drawers is the first step in making getting
dressed easier. If necessary, you can add specific and very simple signs or labels on a drawer or in the closet as reminders of what items to expect in a specific location. See Finding and Seeing Items section
for more helpful solutions.
The next step where vision processing can break down is trying to see where the back or the top of a piece of clothing is or perceiving the right from the left sleeve or left from right pant leg. Some people have reported that the use of a safety pin where the tag is located on the back of a piece of clothing, or at the bottom of one sleeve, can decrease the frustration of putting on a piece of clothing. The use of clothing without buttons or zippers when they become difficult to use is also helpful, although for some people the buttons and zippers help them understand how to orient the clothing item when putting it on. Some people report that putting out an outfit for each day in a very specific manner (face down on the bed, for instance) or keeping an entire outfit on one hanger after items are washed (see Finding and Seeing Items section) is extremely helpful. Trying to “re-learn” how to dress as one used to do is most often not helpful nor is it possible. Instead, creating a “new” way to get dress usually takes trial and error and then with progression of dementia, new approaches become necessary.
Smart Phone Applications for People with Visual Impairment
There are many applications that might help a person with visual brain dysfunction, particularly early in the course. Nearly all, however, were designed for people with low vision or with blindness due to eye diseases.
Thus, some of these might not be helpful for a person with cognitive impairments beyond visual brain dysfunction and the list provided is a means to allow one to explore apps with potential to help.
- Watch: Low vision talking watches: there are many brands and styles to choose from and some are inexpensive and simply give the time when a button is pushed. Others can add recorded reminders or give the time at a specified interval.
- Magnifier: SuperVision+ (Free, iOS and Android), turns your phone into an electronic magnifier. There are many apps that do this, but this one, developed at Harvard, features image stabilization. Visor ($1.99, iOS and Android) is another app that transforms your smart phone into a video magnifier. It has very simple controls for magnification and text/background colors.
- Navigation: For walking navigation using GPS there is Amedia NaviRed (Free, iOS) and Loadstone GPS ($7.99, iOS) and Lazarilla GPS for Blind (Free, Android)
- Color ID: To determine the color of clothing and other objects, there is Color ID (free, iOS and Android) and other similar apps available. Examine Clothes Color (Free, iOS) also describes the pattern on clothing.
- Identification: The following apps use your phone’s camera and artificial intelligence to identify objects in your environment. Depending on the app, some can identify currency, cans in your cupboard, read signs, process bar and QR codes, and recognize colors. Point your phone camera at the object and the app will speak to what it is, such as “Campbell’s Tomato Soup”, or “five dollar bill”. They include Microsoft’s Seeing Al (free, iOS), iDentifi-Object Recognition (Free, iOS), Third Eye: Empowering the Blind (Free, iOS and Android), VocalEyes Al (Free, iOS), and Aipoly Vision (Free, iOS and Android).
- Human Volunteer: If you would like to receive assistance from a human volunteer, you can use Be My Eyes (Free, iOS and Android) or BeSpecular (Free, iOS and Android). Point your phone camera at any item, such as a restaurant menu, a sign or food. You can ask the volunteer a question such as “How much is this check made out for?” and the volunteer will help you make sense of it as you converse with the volunteer. AIRA is not a phone app but utilizes smart glasses to communicate with a trained assistant who receives your GPS coordinates and can see what your smart glasses see. The trained assistant also has access (if you choose to provide) to your social media sites and other preferences, such as preferred foods. The assistant can guide you in traveling to an appointment, help you find a person you might be looking for (if their picture is in one of your social media sites) and helps you order food by looking up the menu of a restaurant you might visit. Price includes the smart glasses and insurance on them, data service and training sessions, and can vary from $89 per month for 100 minutes/month to $329/month for unlimited access.
- Reading Help: MD evReader (free, iOS and Android) and Scroll ‘n Roll ($0.99, iOS) are apps that can display an eBook or other text file as a single “marquee” line of scrolling text. For people who have difficulty tracking their eyes across a row of text, this can make reading easier.
- Watching a Movie: Actiview Movie Access (Free, iOS) makes movies more accessible to the visually (and hearing) impaired by providing audio description or, for the hearing impaired, amplified audio (via earphones), closed captioning or subtitles on your screen. It works in theaters and with movies you watch at home.
- Auditory/Readable Labels for Objects: PENfriend3 Voice Labeling System – Identify objects with voice labels and magnets. The upgraded design replaces the PenFriend2 with four easy to use yellow tactile operating buttons that contrast against black casing. Record your voice and mark household items onto self-adhesive labels. Simple on/off function for recording prevents you from having to hold record button. Transfer MP3 music files to your PenFriend3. 250 plus house of recording time. These can be purchased at many places like MaxiAid.com and Amazon.com.
- Dictation: Microsoft’s Dictate
– Hands Free Typing. How To Install Dictate add-in for Office: Go to
. Instructions are in this link as well. There are many other similar applications that allow you to turn dictations to words and many can be found on smart devices (i.e. apps
that come with the device) or explored in the app store on the device.